Eliza Carthy: “Folk music is sexy and filthy, and you fall over” I live thus

Posted by Mike Schumacher

“I’m a Yorkshire scrub”… Whitby’s Eliza Carthy Christopher Thomond/Guardian


Covid nearly brought her and her illustrious family to ruin. She was the pink-haired fiddler who punked up the people. Eliza Carthy discusses being broke, losing a loved one, and the therapeutic value of booze- and bawdy-themed songs


The Waterson-Carthy folk dynasty’s situation did not seem promising at the beginning of this year. Eliza Carthy described it as a “struggling to survive” situation. After going into a coma and having to relearn how to walk and communicate, her mother, the well-known singer Norma Waterson, was unable to perform for ten years. She had lately been hospitalized for pneumonia and had never fully recovered from her illness. Eliza Carthy, who received an MBE, and her father Martin Carthy, a renowned singer-songwriter, had been left without a source of income as a result of Covid lockdowns. Since they were self-employed, like many artists, they were only eligible for a six-month small business grant rather than a furlough.


“By the third lockdown,” says Carthy, “we were looking at selling our instruments.”


Then, a trusted agency buddy in the US advised Carthy to make a public plea for assistance. She claims, “You wouldn’t believe the people who gave us money.” It’s been both devastating and consoling. Waterson sadly died away in January at the age of 82. Carthy claims, “We weren’t allowed to see her until the last day.” “And at that time, she had left. However, I was able to inform her how much money was in the fund during our FaceTime call. She simply said, “The kids are going to be safe,” as she turned to face me. The home will be secure. And that was the first time in ten years that we had felt that way. She grabs for a tissue to blot the tears that are streaming down her cheeks. She apologizes, “but it’s been so hard.


“I had four glasses of champagne and they found me under a bridge”


We’re seated in the kitchen of their commodiously disorganized family house in the North Yorkshire fishing community of Robin Hood’s Bay. Her 81-year-old father, who inspired Bob Dylan and taught Paul Simon to play Scarborough Fair, is tending to poultry outside the back door. Carthy relocated once again in 2011 and started her own band while still working as a “part-time caregiver and single mother.” Posters for NormaFest, the event she founded in 2015 so that her mother could at least perform locally, are displayed on the wall. Carthy beams at this happy recollection, “She was a typical matriarch – loving yet strict. She wanted me here when I moved back but didn’t want me to touch anything. She chuckles and points to a laptop that is sitting on a kitchen counter. This isn’t your workplace, she’d say. It’s where food is prepared!


‘Ariana Grande is folk, Bohemian Rhapsody is folk’ … Carthy. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian


Carthy has recently gotten back into music. To commemorate the 30 years since she dropped out of her A-levels to pursue a career in music, she will release Queen of the Whirl this month. The album features fan favorites selected by a Twitter vote and re-recorded with her crack band the Restitution. Her parents spearheaded the “folk revival” in the 1960s, but Carthy is attempting to modernize the genre by blending it with rock guitars, reggae rhythms, and sometimes controversial issues, as well as the bawdiness and vulnerability she exhibits in person.


“I object to the Brit-centric definition of folk,” she says, “which is very white and safe and fixated with acoustic instruments.” In her role as president of the English Folk Dance and Song Society, she has been keen to shake things up, diversity-wise. “To me, Ariana Grande is folk music. Bohemian Rhapsody is folk. I define folk as whatever you can sing in a pub – and for people to be able to join in and be as shit as you like. Folk music isn’t clean. It’s sexy and filthy and at the end of the night you fall over. And that’s how I like to live.”


In some cases, very literally. The night her buddy, comedian Stewart Lee, brought her to the world premiere of Jerry Springer: The Opera, which he co-wrote, is detailed in the song Blood on My Boots. After four champagne glasses, Eliza struck the brisk night air and fell. She chuckles, “They discovered me beneath a bridge. My boots genuinely had blood on them.


She remembers picking up the violin for the first time—in her instance, it had been her grandfather’s. She explains, in the best manner imaginable, “I didn’t want to be my dad.” Female fiddlers were less common in the late 1980s and early 1990s, with the exception of Kathryn Tickell and Helen O’Hara, let alone those wearing bovver boots and buzz cuts. You’re selling on your youth and attractiveness, someone commented. I said, “You wot?” She gave her hair pink and blue dye, went on a folk club tour, and survived on four hours of sofa sleep. It was punk, she claims, in certain ways. I once woke up in a bed with snow falling on my face. In a another instance, when her car broke down, she put the fable about sealing a leaking radiator with a dozen eggs to the test. “It failed to function. A radiator just arrived filled with scrambled eggs.


‘Decent people built stages that kept us all alive’ … at Wickham festival in 2015. Photograph: Harry Herd/WireImage


She first encountered some pushback from the more conventional folk group, but when other new artists like Seth Lakeman and Jock Tyldesley emerged, she gradually won their respect. I give the folk scene credit for it, she claims. “I believe they realized that if they didn’t bring in fresh talent, they would simply have to wait for the phone calls informing them that yet another veteran artist had passed away. Instead, they welcomed us inside and demanded that we “show us what you’ve got.” The amazing thing about folk clubs in the 1980s and 1990s was that they held folk up, which is why my dad still plays the clubs. Sometimes we fell on our asses, sometimes we didn’t. These individuals lacked formal promotion experience. They were good individuals who established the structures that kept us all alive—social workers, nurses, and teachers, for example.


Warners signed her up in the hopes of finding “a cross between Joni Mitchell and Judy Garland” after her 1998 album Red Rice, sometimes known as her “drum’n’bass album,” and Anglicana, which was nominated for the Mercury award five years later, were both nominated. Perhaps they didn’t anticipate songs like The Company of Guys, which starts out with the line, “I’ve given blowjobs on couches / To men who didn’t want me any more / Why didn’t they tell me before?”


She chuckles at the thought. “Running into your early 20s self is exciting. There are undoubtedly certain things that I am no longer willing to perform. She claims that Ani DiFranco’s songs about “abortions and stuff” had inspired her and given her the urge to be “completely honest” about a true incidence. The phrase “I don’t want to be one of the beautiful people” is sarcastic since she had her heart shattered. He told me that it didn’t matter since we were the more attractive people when we were still in love: I reflected, “No. I’m a Yorkshire scrubby little jerk, and I don’t really like you. You’re an arsehole and I’m a punk. Her powerful laugh fills the kitchen. She claims that when the song was being prepared for recording, another musician entered the room. Oh Jesus, it’s Nick Cave singing about blowjobs, I thought.


“Music is mathematics – you can actually learn about how arpeggios affect your nervous system”


She now identifies as a “carer.” Her 2019 solo album, Restitute, was recorded in her bedroom and sold online as payment for the band’s mistreatment when they weren’t paid. She has recently been working on creating her next solo album, organizing her father’s 80th birthday concert at the Barbican in London, and teaching music at her former school in Robin Hood’s Bay after being further delayed by the virus. The emotional and spiritual knowledge that music gives from a young age cannot be valued, according to her. The mathematics of music. You may study the scientific principles behind how arpeggios impact your neural system. Music is terribly underappreciated. It may alter your life.


She is beginning to put this year’s sorrows behind her by playing it and re-engaging with others. She said that at first, coming out of the epidemic was stressful for her since it brought back painful memories of her seclusion and suffering. However, anytime we’ve played, I’ve experienced that collectivism once again, along with people and laughing. The epidemic has brought up a number of issues, and I have considered calling so-and-so. It’s been pretty beautiful, too.


On October 28, Queen of the Whirl will be available. On November 23, Eliza Carthy’s UK tour kicks off.


Thanks to Dave Simpson at The Guardian whose reporting provided the original basis for this story.


envelope linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram